Difference between Fixed and Dynamic Channel Allocations
Radio resource management for wireless and cellular networks uses channel allocation strategies to provide bandwidth and communication channels to base stations, access points, and terminal devices.The two types of channel allocation procedures are Fixed Channel Allocation and Dynamic Channel Allocation. We are going toDiscover how these two methods of channel allocation differ from one another by reading this article.
Fixed Channel Allocation
Using the Fixed Channel Allocation (FCA) approach, cells are given a specific number of voice or data channels. Once the channels have been assigned to certain cells, they cannot be changed. Frequency reuse is enhanced when channels are assigned in FCA. If a user tries to call while the cell is already in use, the call is rejected. The answer to this issue is to take the channels from other cells.When there are a few constant users and a consistent stream of homogenous network traffic, fixed channel allocation schemes are chosen. Because the allocation method is straightforward, it can do without the overhead of complicated algorithms. Additionally, since each user is given a specific channel that is not shared with others, there is no interference between the users.
Dynamic Channel Allocation
Dynamic channel allocation is a method of allocating channels where channels are not permanently assigned to cells. A user's request for a call is sent by the Base Station (BS) to the Mobile Station Center (MSC) for voice channel or channel allocation. This lessens the likelihood that calls may be blocked. Additional channels are assigned when traffic volume increases, and the opposite is also true.Since DCA modifies the bandwidth allocation based on traffic volume, it is especially well suited for busy traffic. DCA techniques, however, put more strain on the system's processing and storage resources.
Advantages of Fixed Channel Allocation
- There are a lot of advantages in using the fixed channel allocation system in the channel management. The following are some of the advantages.
- The Fixed Channel Allocation gives the best performance when there are very limited or fixed number of users are present.
- The Fixed Channel have a very basic and simple allocation of channel.
- There is no need of incurring the overhead complex algorithms.
- The users do not get interfered with each other because every user will be allocated with a particular channel.
Advantages of Dynamic Channel Allocation
- The Dynamic channel allocation allots the channels for the users as per the requirements of the user.
- By the help of the Dynamic Channel Allocation the network resources will not be overly used.
- When using voice transmission, there are fewer opportunities for service denial and call blocking.
Disadvantages of Fixed Channel Allocation
- It is not very much suitable in these days because the number of users is increased a lot and it cannot handle the large number of users or clients.
- When the number of users will be increased the bandwidth of each user channel will be decreased.
Disadvantages of Dynamic Channel Allocation
- When the Dynamic channel allocation is used, it increases the load on the system.
- The Dynamic channel allocation consumes large memory storage of the system.
Difference between Fixed and Dynamic Channel Allocations
Fixed Channel Allocation | Dynamic Channel Allocation |
In the Fixed channel allocation system, cells are provided with the limited number of channels or voice channels. | In the Dynamic channel allocation system, the cells or user cells are not fixed. |
The user call is blocked if every channel is in use. | If all channels are blocked, the Base Station (BS) asks the Mobile Station Center for additional channels (MSC). |
Frequency reuse is increased since the cellular channels are spaced apart as little as possible. | Due to random channel allocation, frequency reuse is not maximized. |
In the Fixed channel allocation only, simple algorithms are used, and it is also easy to maintain. | In the Dynamic channel allocation system, there are many complex algorithms are used. |
Fixed channel allocation is less expensive when it is compared to Dynamic channel allocation. | It is more expensive when it is compared to the Fixed channel allocation. |
In FCA, the cell keeps the designated channels after a call has ended. | The voice channel or channel is returned to the MSC after a call is finished in DCA. |
In the event of FCA, the Mobile Station Center will have less work to do. | In the event of DCA, the Mobile Station Center has a high signal load and additional tasks. |